Dachau 2023—Lessons to be Learned

Since 2017, I have been writing and researching the evils thrust upon Europe and beyond by the NSDAP or in short Nazis, but I had never visited a concentration camp until last Sunday—4 June 2023.

I will not just write about Dachau but include the place I visited the day before—Das NS-Dokumentationszentrum München—the National Socialists Documentation Centre.

Dachau

I selected the Dachau Concentration Camp to visit rather than Auschwitz Concentration Camp because, historically, Dachau was the first concentration camp built. It started here. Dachau was established on 22 March 1933, only a few weeks after Hitler and the Nazis had seized power.

I will not go into great lengths on the history of the place. I have written about it several times before. I will focus more about my observations, emotions and experiences of my visit.

We had an Irish tour guide. The tour started in Munich at the Marienplatz and from there on the train to Dachau town.

When we arrived, I could not help but notice how picturesque and pretty Dachau town was. Straight away, I saw a paradox of beauty and evil. When we arrived at the KZ-Gedenkstätte Dachau, the Dachau Memorial Centre, it was explained to us that we should not refer to it as a concentration camp but—as a former concentration camp. It is now also officially a cemetery, as estimated remains of 20,000 prisoners are buried and scattered over the site. One thing I found bizarre—but also something I could understand—was the location of the shop and cafe—they were at the complex’s entrance.

The gate at the entrance of the camp is a replica.

The gate in Dachau went missing in 2014. In 2016, it resurfaced in Bergen, Norway. There, it had been heavily exposed to the elements and could no longer function as a gate. In the meantime, a local blacksmith had made a replica, which is currently still in use.

What puzzled me about the story is that the original gate weighs about 100 kg, so it needed more than one man to steal it. Secondly, they had to climb over the outer gate of the Dachau complex and then move the stolen gate over the fence. Thirdly, the adjacent previous SS camp, which now is home to the Bavarian Riot Police, they didn’t hear or see anything, Call me cynical, but I doubt that very much.

The original gate is now on display in the former camp.

While walking around the premises, I did notice a few ladies wearing quite revealing clothes. Now I am the last man on the planet who would generally not have a problem with that, but there is a time and a place, and this was not the time nor the place.

I could have taken hundreds of photographs, but out of respect for the site, I took only a few shots where I knew I could tell a story.

As you enter the camp, one of the first things you would see [photo above] is the grassy verge and the watchtower. If prisoners stepped on the grass, the tower guards would fire upon them. Sometimes prisoners would deliberately step on it, knowing it was suicide. That was the level of desperation many in Dachau had.

Prisoners faced torture in many ways. One of the cruellest was when put on a bench face down and beaten with a club. They had to count every beat they received in German. A mistake led to the beating starting over. Eventually, the punishment was limited to 25 whacks, but the sadistic guards were such that they found a way around it. They would have more guards do the beatings— meaning it was 25 beatings per guard.

Although murder by gassing was sporadically at Dachau, it did happen. When I stood in the middle of the gas chamber, I did become overwhelmed. To me, it is still hard to fathom the evil of it. It could take up to 20 minutes before people would die. I could have taken pictures in the gas chambers but didn’t out of respect.

On 13 September 1944, there was an execution of four women at Dachau Concentration Camp. The four: Yolande Beekman, Elaine Plewman, Madeleine Damerment, and Noor-un-nisa Inayat Khan—were agents of the Special Operations Executive. A Dutch prisoner at the camp reported that Noor, in particular, had been singled out and beaten near death before being shot.

Before execution, the four women were tortured in the crematorium, facing the ovens where eventually their bodies would end up. I found one of the most disturbing aspects. Murdering is one thing, but why the mental and physical torture before that?

The tour lasted 3 hours. Over the next few weeks, I will write more about it, but as I said earlier, I also visited the Das NS-Dokumentationszentrum München’ the National Socialists Documentation Centre.

Das NS-Dokumentationszentrum München

Munich is associated with the rise of National Socialism like no other city and where the Das. NS-Dokumentationszentrum Münich [NSDAP] was founded. The tour of Munich and National Socialism was also about the documents of the city’s Nazi history.

I will not go into depth on all the details, but I want to touch on a few things. Firstly I was impressed with the museum. It gave me some food for thought, mainly that we have to relook at how we teach the Holocaust. Yes, Dachau was the first concentration camp built by the Nazis, but the Holocaust started with antisemitism, bigotry, racism, indifference and intolerance and all these ‘ingredients’ are plentiful again.

The museum exhibited a post-World War I and Weimar Era. Between 1924 and 1929, although a conservative city, Munich was an apolitically and socially diverse city. Life was good, albeit funded by loans given by Americans and British institutions. The differences between the majority conservative population and the more liberate-minded citizens—have never been addressed. However, there was an upswing of prosperity, and it seemed not to matter. When the financial crash happened in 1929, causing the Great Depression, ending the city’s economy. Münich became divided again. It wasn’t unique to just Munich but to other German cities.

It will have escaped no one that diversity and inclusivity are all the buzzwords today, and I don’t say this to be sarcastic. If we don’t address the differences between different groups of people and acknowledge the fears and concerns on all sides, diversity and inclusivity are just—buzzwords.

One group of victims of the Nazi regime were homosexual men. I noticed one photograph that I describe as ironic. It was what the Nazis saw as true Germanic art, unlike the degenerate art by mainly Jewish artists.

It was a photograph by Hitler’s photographer, Heinrich Hoffman, of statues of naked men [see above] and two men, in particular, holding hands, nude! I will leave it to you to interpret that one for yourselves. However, I think it’s obvious. There is a new upsurge of violence against the LBTQ community in several countries, and governments are introducing similar laws to those from 1930s Germany.

The above photograph is from 1938, and at first glance, it looks like an innocent, everyday picture of a young boy standing outside a hairdressing salon. His mother might work there, or perhaps he’s resting while she is getting her hair done. Look closer at the sign in the bottom left corner. It states, “Jews not welcome.”

I also visited the Jewish Museum in Münich. One thing that struck me was the persecution of Jews, in one way or another, since the 13th century. For us to ensure a Holocaust will never happen again, we need to find out what the root is for all that hate. As Primo Levi once said, “It happened, and thus it can happen again.”

I will do a follow-up in a few weeks because I have too much material to write on Dachau that I couldn’t possibly write up in just one post.

sources

https://www.nsdoku.de/

Karl Amadeus Hartmann— Protesting Against the Nazi Regime Through Music

Today marks the 117th birthday of Karl Amadeus Hartmann. He was born on 2 August 1905 in Munich and came into contact with art and music at an early stage. He studied trombone and composition at the Staatliche Akademie der Tonkunst in Munich from 1924 to 1929.

He hated Nazism and Hitler and anything that ranked extreme socialism and communism. A fellow composer, Udo Zimmermann, said about Hartmann, “His concept of life oriented towards humanity is inscribed in all his scores. A warning in view of the atrocities of this world, but also resistance from the heart: revocation of the spirits, love and life.”

His compositions were often politically charged, as Hartmann was a socialist who staunchly opposed the Nazis and fascism. During World War II, Hartmann half-poisoned himself to avoid military conscription.

He voluntarily withdrew completely from musical life in Germany during the Nazi era, while remaining in Germany, and refused to allow his works to be played there. An early symphonic poem, “Miserae” (1933–1934, first performed in Prague, 1935) was condemned by the Nazi regime but his work continued to be performed, and his fame grew abroad. A number of Hartmann’s compositions show the profound effect of the political climate. His “Miserae” (1933–34) was dedicated to his friends…who sleep for all eternity; we do not forget you (Dachau, 1933–34), referring to Dachau Concentration Camp, and was condemned by the Nazis. His “Piano Sonata 27 April 1945,” is about the thousands of prisoners from Dachau, whom Hartmann witnessed being led away from Allied forces at the end of the war.

Just three days before the liberation of the Dachau camp, the SS forced approximately 7,000 prisoners on a death march from Dachau, south to Tegernsee. During the six-day death march, anyone who could not keep up or continued was shot. Many died of exposure, hunger, or exhaustion. American forces liberate the Dachau Concentration Camp on 29 April 1945. In early May 1945, American troops liberate the surviving prisoners from the death march to Tegernsee.

Solly Ganor, a survivor said about the march, “We could see the furtive parting of curtains as German civilians peered out at us. To our surprise, a few of them came out and tried to offer us some bread, but the result was disastrous. Hundreds of starving inmates would descend on the benefactor, often knocking him or her down. The bread was immediately torn to pieces, and the guards set upon the mob. Each time this happened several more bodies were left by the side of the road.”

After the fall of the Nazi regime, Hartmann was one of the few prominent surviving anti-fascists in Bavaria whom the postwar Allied administration could appoint to a position of responsibility. In 1945, he became a dramaturge at the Bavarian State Opera and there, as one of the few internationally recognized figures who had survived untainted by any collaboration with the Nazi regime, he became a vital figure in the rebuilding of (West) German musical life. Perhaps his most notable achievement was the “Musica Viva” concert series, which he founded and ran for the rest of his life in Munich.

He died on 5 December 1963 in Munich.

Although Hartmann is one of the greatest German composers of the 20th century, he is forgotten in the English-speaking world.

sources

https://holocaustmusic.ort.org/politics-and-propaganda/hartmann-karl-amadeus/

https://archive.ph/20130104153710/http://www.schott-music.com/shop/persons/featured/8399/index.html#selection-559.0-559.208

Christoph Probst-Executed February 22.1943.

Not every German supported the Nazis or signed up to their ideology. There were quite a few who were appalled by what their nation had become under the leadership of Hitler and his regime.

However there were only a handful of people who had the courage to stand up against the Nazis, at risk of their own lives. Some of these were an organisation that called themselves “White Rose”

It was a resistance group in Munich . The group, founded in June 1942, consisted of students from the Ludwig-Maximilians-University of Munich who distributed leaflets against the Nazis policies.

Sophie and Hans Scholl were the prominent members , and so much has already been written about the Scholl siblings. I want to focus a bit more on another member, Christoph Probst.

Probst had a lot more to lose the the Scholl siblings, although he was young, he was married with 3 children.

Born in Murnau/Upper Bavaria on November 6, 1919, Probst studied medicines in Munich after his labor and military service in 1939.

In 1941 Christoph he married Herta Dohrn, with whom he later had three children. Alexander Schmorell, a friend of his, introduced Probst to Hans Scholl and his group of friends in the summer of 1942.

Christoph Probst joined the White Rose rather late, as he did not belong to the same student group as Hans Scholl, Alexander Schmorell and Willi Graf, and stayed for the most part in the background. He had to consider the safety of his family. He belonged, together with the Scholl siblings, Graf and Schmorell to the tightest circle, into which university professor Kurt Huber also came.

The White Rose produced, printed and distributed, at the risk of their lives, six leaflets in all.

Although Probst had been transferred to Innsbruck in December 1942, he was still actively involved in the discussion of the fifth White Rose leaflet on his visits to Munich and was also prepared to write his own flyer. After Sophie and Hans Scholl were arrested, on February 18 1943, the Gestapo found a draft leaflet written by Probst in Hans Scholl’s jacket pocket, stating: “Hitler and his regime must fall so that Germany may live on.” Christoph Probst was arrested in Innsbruck on February 20, 1943. To his mother he wrote whilst in prison.

“By an unlikely mishap I have now found myself in an awkward position. I don’t sugarcoat anything when I tell you that I’m fine and that I’m very calm. The treatment is good and life in the cell seems so tolerable to me that I’m not afraid of a longer period of imprisonment… I’m only concerned for you, for the wife and the small children”

On 22 February 1943, Christoph Probst and the Scholls were tried and sentenced together at the Volksgerichtshof by judge Roland Freisler, who had already determined the sentences even before the trial had started.

All three were sentenced to death by guillotine. Their sentences were carried out on the very same day at Stadelheim Prison, Munich. Probst had asked for clemency during interrogation. He also requested a trial for the sake of his wife and three children, who were aged three years, two years and four weeks old. His wife, Herta Probst, was sick with childbed fever at the time.

Shortly before Christoph was executed, he was allowed a visit from a Catholic Priest. Christoph requested baptism into the Catholic faith.

The only consolation to this is that his wife Herta survived the war and died 21 September 2016 aged 102

sources

https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/white-rose

https://www.britannica.com/topic/White-Rose#ref1111344

https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/the-white-rose-a-lesson-in-dissent

https://www.newworldencyclopedia.org/entry/Christoph_Probst

https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/171854367/herta-siebler-probst

https://www.gdw-berlin.de/en/recess/biographies/index_of_persons/biographie/view-bio/christoph-probst/?no_cache=1

Donation

I am passionate about my site and I know you all like reading my blogs. I have been doing this at no cost and will continue to do so. All I ask is for a voluntary donation of $2, however if you are not in a position to do so I can fully understand, maybe next time then. Thank you. To donate click on the credit/debit card icon of the card you will use. If you want to donate more then $2 just add a higher number in the box left from the PayPal link. Many thanks.

$2.00

Munich 1972

Ap_munich905_t

In the early morning hours of September 5 1972, six members of the Arab terrorist group known as Black September dressed in the Olympic sweat suits of Arab nations and jumped the fence surrounding the Olympic village in Munich, Germany, carrying bags filled with guns. Although guards spotted them, they paid little attention because athletes often jumped the fence during the competition to return to their living quarters.

black september

After changing into disguises, the terrorists, toting machine guns, burst into the apartments of 21 Israeli athletes and officials. Yossef Gutfreund, a wrestling referee who valiantly tried to keep the terrorists out, saved Tuvia Sokolovsky, who was able to climb out a window and escape. In another apartment, Moshe Weinberg was shot 12 times but still managed to wound one of the terrorists and save the life of one of his teammates.

Israeli-olympic-team

Created in 1970 by a few survivors of the “ten terrible September days” of fighting against Jordan for a Palestinian homeland, Black September succeeded in taking nine hostages before demanding the release of 234 prisoners-most of whom were Arab terrorists. The demands were categorically refused, but it was eventually agreed that the terrorists and the hostages would be taken to the Furstenfeldbruck airport by helicopter and given a plane.

60 Jahre Bundesrepublik - Olympia-Attentat

The German government planned an ambush at the airport, stationing sharpshooters around the runway and officers in the airplane. However, the plan quickly disintegrated when the officers in the plane, worried about their lack of preparation, deserted. There weren’t nearly enough sharpshooters to effectively take down all of the terrorists either, partly because the Germans didn’t realize that two other terrorists had joined the Black September attack.

Still, the ambush was carried out. Three terrorists were taken out in the first wave of shots, but the others were able to hide out of range. One threw a grenade into a helicopter where five hostages were still tied up, instantly killing them all. Another terrorist fired his machine gun into another helicopter, killing the remaining hostages.

Twenty hours after Black September had begun their attack, a German police official, 5 Palestinian terrorists, and 11 Israeli athletes lay dead.

munichathletes

Three of the terrorists who survived were imprisoned but were set free a month later when Arabs hijacked a Lufthansa 727 and demanded their release.

A few days after the tragic event at the Olympics, Israel retaliated with air strikes against Syria and Lebanon, killing 66 people and wounding dozens. In addition, Israel sent out assassination squads to hunt down members of Black September while Israeli troops broke through the Lebanese border, igniting the heaviest fighting since the Six-Day War of 1967.

Initially some newspapers had reported 9 athletes killed.

Sun Newspaper headline

ny times

Of those believed to have planned the massacre, only Abu Daoud, the man who claims that the attack was his idea, is known to have died of natural causes. Historical documents released to Der Spiegel by the German secret service show willipohlthat Dortmund police had been aware of collaboration between Abu Daoud and neo-Nazi Willi Pohl (de) (aka E. W. Pless and, since 1979, officially named Willi Voss) seven weeks before the attack.